What are the different types of code review?

Free Coding Questions Catalog

Boost your coding skills with our essential coding questions catalog. Take a step towards a better tech career now!

Different Types of Code Review

Code reviews are essential for maintaining high-quality software and fostering collaborative development environments. They help identify bugs, improve code readability, and ensure adherence to coding standards. Understanding the different types of code reviews can help teams choose the most effective approach for their workflow. Here are the primary types of code reviews commonly used in software development.

1. Over-the-Shoulder Review

Over-the-shoulder reviews are informal and involve one developer reviewing another developer's code by sitting together. This type of review allows for immediate feedback and discussion, fostering a collaborative environment.

Benefits of Over-the-Shoulder Review

Immediate Feedback: Quick identification and resolution of issues.
Collaborative Learning: Developers can learn from each other in real-time.
Flexibility: Easily adaptable to different team sizes and project scopes.

2. Email Pass-Around Review

In an email pass-around review, code changes are sent via email to a group of reviewers who provide feedback asynchronously. This method is useful for distributed teams or when immediate face-to-face interaction is not feasible.

Benefits of Email Pass-Around Review

Asynchronous Feedback: Allows reviewers to provide input at their convenience.
Documentation: Creates a written record of feedback and discussions.
Scalability: Suitable for larger teams with multiple stakeholders.

3. Tool-Assisted Review

Tool-assisted reviews use specialized software to manage the code review process. Tools like GitHub Pull Requests, GitLab Merge Requests, and Bitbucket Pull Requests provide a structured environment for reviewing code changes.

Benefits of Tool-Assisted Review

Structured Process: Ensures consistency and thoroughness in reviews.
Integration: Seamlessly integrates with version control systems and CI/CD pipelines.
Traceability: Maintains a history of changes and feedback for future reference.

4. Pair Programming

Pair programming involves two developers working together on the same codebase simultaneously. One developer writes the code while the other reviews each line in real-time, promoting continuous code quality checks.

Benefits of Pair Programming

Continuous Review: Immediate detection and correction of issues.
Knowledge Sharing: Facilitates the transfer of skills and best practices between team members.
Enhanced Collaboration: Strengthens team cohesion and communication.

5. Formal Code Review

Formal code reviews follow a strict process with predefined steps, roles, and documentation. This type of review is often used in regulated industries where compliance and thoroughness are critical.

Benefits of Formal Code Review

Comprehensive Evaluation: Ensures all aspects of the code are thoroughly examined.
Compliance: Meets industry standards and regulatory requirements.
Accountability: Clearly defined roles and responsibilities enhance accountability.

6. Walkthrough

A walkthrough is a semi-formal review where the author guides the reviewers through the code changes, explaining the logic and design decisions. This type of review emphasizes understanding and knowledge sharing rather than strict evaluation.

Benefits of Walkthrough

Educational: Helps team members understand the codebase and design choices.
Collaborative: Encourages open discussion and collective problem-solving.
Flexible: Can be adapted to different levels of formality based on team needs.

Recommended Courses

Enhance your understanding of code reviews and improve your coding practices by exploring the following courses:

These courses provide valuable insights and strategies to master coding interviews and refine your coding practices, enhancing your ability to conduct effective code reviews.