2551. Put Marbles in Bags - Detailed Explanation
Problem Statement
You are given an integer array weights
where weights[i]
is the weight of the i-th marble. You need to split all the marbles into exactly m
bags. Each bag must contain a contiguous sequence of marbles. The cost of a bag is defined as the sum of the weight of the first marble and the weight of the last marble in that bag. The total cost of a distribution is the sum of the costs of all m
bags.
Formally, if you split the array into m
contiguous subarrays (bags), then the cost is computed as:
cost = (first marble of bag 1 + last marble of bag 1) + (first marble of bag 2 + last marble of bag 2) + … + (first marble of bag m + last marble of bag m)
Notice that the first marble of the first bag is always weights[0]
and the last marble of the last bag is always weights[n-1]
(where n
is the length of weights
). For any split between marbles, the two marbles adjacent to the split both contribute to the total cost (one as the last marble of one bag and one as the first marble of the next bag).
Your goal is to compute the difference between the maximum total cost and the minimum total cost over all valid ways to split the marbles into m
bags.
Hints
-
Observing the Fixed Base Cost:
Since every valid split always usesweights[0]
as the first marble of the first bag andweights[n-1]
as the last marble of the last bag, the termweights[0] + weights[n-1]
is common to every distribution. -
Role of Splits:
When you split the array intom
bags, you make exactlym - 1
splits. For a split between indicesi
andi+1
, the contribution to the cost isweights[i] + weights[i+1]
. These contributions are “additive” in the sense that the total cost can be viewed as a fixed base cost plus the sum of contributions from them - 1
splits. -
Optimization by Sorting:
To minimize the total cost, you want to choose them - 1
splits with the smallest contributions. Conversely, to maximize the total cost, choose them - 1
splits with the largest contributions. The answer is the difference between these two sums.
Approach
-
Compute the Base Cost:
The base cost is the sum of the first marble in the first bag and the last marble in the last bag: [ \text{base} = \text{weights}[0] + \text{weights}[n-1] ] This part is fixed regardless of how you split the array. -
Calculate Candidate Split Contributions:
For each possible split between marbles (i.e. between index (i) and (i+1) for (0 \le i < n-1)), calculate: [ \text{contribution}[i] = \text{weights}[i] + \text{weights}[i+1] ] These represent the extra cost incurred if you choose that particular split. -
Select Splits for Minimum and Maximum Cost:
- Sort the list of contributions.
- For the minimum total cost, sum the smallest (m - 1) contributions.
- For the maximum total cost, sum the largest (m - 1) contributions.
-
Calculate Total Costs and Their Difference:
- (\text{minCost} = \text{base} + \text{sum of smallest } (m-1) \text{ contributions})
- (\text{maxCost} = \text{base} + \text{sum of largest } (m-1) \text{ contributions})
- The answer is: [ \text{answer} = \text{maxCost} - \text{minCost} ]
Complexity Analysis
-
Time Complexity:
- Calculating the candidate contributions takes (O(n)).
- Sorting these contributions takes (O(n \log n)).
- Summing (m-1) elements is (O(m)), which is (O(n)) in the worst case.
- Overall time complexity: (O(n \log n)).
-
Space Complexity:
- We use an extra array to store (n-1) candidate contributions, resulting in (O(n)) space.
Python Code
Java Code
Step-by-Step Walkthrough and Visual Examples
-
Base Cost Calculation:
- For an array
weights
, the fixed part isweights[0] + weights[n-1]
.
For example, ifweights = [1, 3, 5, 1]
, thenbase = 1 + 1 = 2
.
- For an array
-
Compute Candidate Contributions:
- For each adjacent pair in
weights
, compute the sum:- Between 1 and 3: (1 + 3 = 4)
- Between 3 and 5: (3 + 5 = 8)
- Between 5 and 1: (5 + 1 = 6)
- Candidate contributions list becomes:
[4, 8, 6]
.
- For each adjacent pair in
-
Sort Contributions:
- Sorted contributions:
[4, 6, 8]
.
- Sorted contributions:
-
Determine Minimum and Maximum Cost:
- To form
m
bags, we need to choosem - 1
splits. - For example, if
m = 2
, choose 1 split.- Minimum cost:
base + smallest contribution = 2 + 4 = 6
. - Maximum cost:
base + largest contribution = 2 + 8 = 10
.
- Minimum cost:
- The answer is the difference:
10 - 6 = 4
.
- To form
-
General Case:
- If
m > 2
, you would sum the smallestm - 1
values for the minimum cost and the largestm - 1
values for the maximum cost, and then take the difference.
- If
Common Mistakes
-
Incorrect Candidate Calculation:
Make sure to correctly compute the contribution for each possible split (adjacent marble pair). -
Ignoring the Base Cost:
The base cost (weights[0] + weights[n-1]
) is common to both the minimum and maximum cost and must be included before comparing the sums. -
Off-by-One Errors:
Remember that if there aren
marbles, there are exactlyn - 1
possible splits, and you must choose exactlym - 1
splits.
Edge Cases
-
Minimum Input Size:
Whenweights
has only 2 marbles (n = 2) andm = 1
, there is only one bag, so the cost is simplyweights[0] + weights[1]
, and the difference is 0. -
All Weights Equal:
When all marbles have the same weight, every candidate contribution is equal; hence, the maximum and minimum cost will be the same and the answer is 0. -
m equals n:
In this scenario, every marble becomes its own bag (except that bags require at least one marble, so m = n means every adjacent pair is a split); the computed difference should reflect the sum of all candidate contributions differences.
Alternative Variations
-
Different Cost Functions:
Instead of using the sum of the first and last elements, the cost might be defined in a different way. The approach of identifying a fixed base and contributions can still be applied with modifications. -
Maximization/Minimization Problems:
Similar techniques can be used when the objective is to maximize or minimize the total cost rather than finding the difference.
Related Problems
-
Split Array Largest Sum:
A problem where the goal is to split an array to minimize the maximum subarray sum, which involves similar partitioning techniques.
GET YOUR FREE
Coding Questions Catalog
