2502. Design Memory Allocator - Detailed Explanation
Problem Statement
You are tasked with designing a memory allocator that manages a contiguous block of memory of a given size. The allocator must support two operations:
-
allocate(size, mID):
Allocate a contiguous block of free memory of the given size and mark it with the memory ID (mID). The allocation should use the first available block (i.e., with the smallest starting index). If a suitable block is found, return its starting index (0-indexed). Otherwise, return -1. -
free(mID):
Free all memory units that have been allocated with the specified mID, making those units available for future allocations. Return the total number of memory units that were freed.
Initially, all memory units are free.
Hints
-
Memory Representation:
Represent the memory as an array where each element holds 0 if it is free or a positive integer representing the mID if it is allocated. -
Allocation Strategy:
To maximize usage, iterate over the memory array to find the first contiguous sequence of free cells that is long enough to satisfy the allocation request. -
Freeing Memory:
When freeing, simply scan through the memory array, resetting any cell with the given mID to 0 and counting how many cells were freed.
Approaches
Brute Force Approach
-
Idea:
Use a simple array to model the memory. For allocation, scan from the beginning and check each possible starting position to see if a block of the required size is available. For freeing, iterate through the entire array and reset cells that match the given mID. -
Steps for allocate:
- Initialize a counter for free contiguous cells.
- Iterate through the memory array.
- Increase the counter when a free cell (value 0) is found.
- When the counter reaches the requested size, mark those cells with mID and return the starting index.
- If the block is interrupted by an allocated cell, reset the counter.
-
Steps for free:
- Iterate through the memory array.
- For each cell matching mID, set it to 0 and increment a freed counter.
- Return the total freed counter.
-
Complexity:
- Time:
allocate
: O(n) per call (n is the total memory size) in the worst case.free
: O(n) per call.
- Space: O(n) for the memory array.
- Time:
Optimized Considerations
While the brute force approach is straightforward, further optimization (such as using interval trees or segment trees) could improve performance for a very large memory space and frequent operations. However, for many practical cases and interview settings, the brute force method is acceptable and simpler to implement.
Complexity Analysis
-
Time Complexity:
allocate
: O(n) in the worst case if the allocator needs to scan the entire memory.free
: O(n) in the worst case.
-
Space Complexity:
- O(n) to store the memory representation.
Python Code
Java Code
Step-by-Step Walkthrough and Visual Examples
-
Initialization:
- The memory array is created with a size provided (for example, 10).
- All cells in the memory array are initially set to 0, indicating that they are free.
-
Allocation Example:
- First Call:
allocate(3, 1)
- The function scans the memory from index 0.
- It finds that the first three cells (indices 0, 1, 2) are free.
- These cells are allocated with mID 1 and the starting index 0 is returned.
- Second Call:
allocate(3, 2)
- The function continues scanning and finds that indices 3, 4, 5 are free.
- These cells are allocated with mID 2 and the starting index 3 is returned.
- First Call:
-
Freeing Example:
- Call:
free(1)
- The function iterates through the memory array.
- It resets all cells that have mID 1 (indices 0, 1, 2) to 0 and counts them.
- It returns the number of freed cells (which is 3).
- Call:
-
Subsequent Allocation:
- Call:
allocate(2, 3)
- After freeing, the function scans and can now allocate a block of 2 free cells (for instance, starting at index 0, if available).
- The cells are marked with mID 3 and the starting index is returned.
- Call:
Common Mistakes
-
Not Resetting the Free Counter:
Forgetting to reset the free counter when an allocated cell is encountered can lead to incorrect detection of contiguous free blocks. -
Overwriting Memory State:
When freeing memory, ensure that only cells with the specified mID are freed and that the memory state is accurately updated. -
Ignoring Edge Cases:
Handle cases where the allocation size is greater than the total memory available or when there is no sufficient contiguous free block.
Edge Cases
-
No Available Block:
If no contiguous block of the requested size is available, the allocate method should return -1. -
Freeing Non-Existent mID:
If the mID is not present in the memory, the free method should return 0.
Alternative Variations
-
Optimized Allocation:
Using advanced data structures (e.g., segment trees or balanced trees) to keep track of free intervals can improve the efficiency of allocation, especially for very large memory sizes or frequent operations. -
Different Allocation Policies:
Instead of choosing the first available block, you might choose the smallest block that fits the size (best-fit) or the largest free block (worst-fit).
Related Problems
GET YOUR FREE
Coding Questions Catalog